General impression of report: professional, organised, confidence inspiring etc?
My general impression is a professional, and well organised report structure with no thick walls of text, and a good looking logo for the group.
ETSF25 · Project draft 1
Written feedback on the ETSF25 project draft, lifted out of plain text and laid out question by question.
/ to search
Document 01
Review of the ETSF25 project draft.
Reviewer’s summary
I think your draft1 is a good starting point with an interesting business idea, and with some small change to your business model. It will become much better! Good work!
Instructions for the reviewer
My general impression is a professional, and well organised report structure with no thick walls of text, and a good looking logo for the group.
I think the problem (event planning in existing apps is clunky) and the proposed solution (a dedicated event app for private/public events) are clearly communicated.
The report explains the customer perspective well and uses the results from the Mom Test they conducted to confirm that students struggle with messy and finding venues.
No, the idea is not completely new; apps like Partiful and Luma already solve the friction-free invitation problem. However, this venture combines private event invitations with venue booking which make it stand out more. The report should acknowledge these competitors and not only compare itself to platforms like Facebook event and Orbi.
The main advantage I can see compared to other alternatives is a cleaner, more dedicated interface for private student events, which I think is very easy for competitors to copy.
As I understand the money will be earned through events, venue booking commissions, and targeted ads, which keeps the app free for students. While I understand the idea I can not help to think that the venue commissions may be a bit unrealistic early on since students rarely want to pay to rent commercial venues for private parties.
I think the business model mostly fits the service well, since they have decided to keep the application free for students (who are less likely to want to pay and are the early adopters) while it generates revenue from venues and organizations .
I can’t see a statement in the report where initial venture capital or startup funding will come from, it only states the revenue stream when the application is live.
The team highlights their technical skills and gaps in marketing, business, and law, so maybe recruiting a business co-founder is more realistic than hiring external consultants (mostly in theory tho).I can see in the appendix A.3 lists everyone's hours, I can also see that some members provide much more specific task breakdowns than others.
I think with their strong tech skills and Lund student network give them a solid shot at building a local prototype, but commercial success is moderate.
The report seems to identify venues, student organizations, and advertisers as paying clients. But something I find unclear is if the free users (the students who use the app to go to events) are customers? A solution might be to clearly separate the free and paying customers.
I think they have correctly identified local student platforms like Orbi, Hitract, and Stuk alongside Facebook Events and Ticketmaster. Some more relevant competitors are Partiful and Luma which already solve the friction-free invitation problem.
I think the product-market is fitting and is mostly motivated by personal experience and Mom Test interviews. Through prototyping, they can validate whether guests will actually download a new app.
Yes the initially target market (student in universities) is realistic, since Lund university has around 41000 enrolled students.
I think that campus word of mouth, hosting their own events, and partnering with student organizations are trustworthy,it is a low-cost way to reach Lund students.
Document 02
Review of the ETSF25 project draft.
Reviewer’s summary
Good report but the business model needs improvements
The report was easy to follow and contained relevant stuff. I thought it was relatively professional and it motivated why they believe in their idea.
It was overall easy to read but I found a few small language faults. For example “The team competence gaps…” should be “team’s” and “The realistic initial market for this venture is the city of Lund, here we ourselves have many connections,” should be “where” instead of “here” i believe. The problem is the struggle of planning events and inviting people and their solution is a new software focused more on the private person.
Yes, it describes well from a user’s perspective. Maybe the line about that many of the interviewees have been using social media recently and that it can be used for marketing is a bit unnecessary, or can at least be moved further down, cause I think it is pretty obvious that most students/young people are using social media more or less. The other parts about the MOM-test I think are very good and show that a problem exists with the current solutions that exist.
Not completely new but a bit different from the ones they mention and what I know. The biggest difference is that the main focus of the app is hosting events and more focus on the private consumer.
I think the biggest difference compared to existing alternatives is that events will be the main focus for the app rather than an extra feature and that it focuses more on the private person. I think that it is pretty easy to copy but since this group has people currently studying it will give them an edge in understanding the problem well. I think when the app has got a lot of users it will be hard to compete with but in the beginning when not a lot are using it another company could steal their potential future users.
It will generate revenue from event holders that want their event to be featured and also a small fee for the event venues when they get a reservation. Possible also from ads in the future. Not sure if it is realistic. If it costs to feature an event a lot of event holders might use for example Facebook instead and do it for free. If it is cheaper to reserve venues at other places it might also be tough to get people to pay extra for a reservation.
From what I have written previously I think that it is a good idea but a bit difficult to generate revenue.
Not sure exactly where the venture capital will be coming from.
I think that it is described well and includes both their strengths and what is missing. Contribution is also described well in the appendix. Very organized appendix.
I think it will be very difficult in the beginning of the project until it potentially has a lot of users cause it is difficult to invite people to an event if most people you want to invite don’t have the app. I also think it will be difficult to find ways of generating revenue until it has become an app that most students have and use. If it has a large user base event holders might pay a little extra to feature and promote their event on the app but if it doesn’t have a lot of users it will be hard to compete with already commonly used alternatives.
It is clear that students who are hosting or joining events are the users. Exactly who the customers are and how you make money from it might be a bit unclear I think.
They mention Facebook, Orbi, Hitract, Stuk and Ticketmaster and I can’t really think of any else.
That their app is actually better and easier to use for a private consumer because I think that is where they think they stand out compared to competitors.
Yes, it is realistic to start with students in Lund and then grow to other cities as well.
As I wrote before, the biggest problem will be to get an initial big user base and reach out to enough people. If a big amount of people use the app then I think getting more people will be very easy because then you need the app to not miss out on events.
Document 03
Review of the ETSF25 project draft.
Reviewer’s summary
Overall a very nice and well written report. As I have written in my peer review I think the biggest problem will be to get a big initial user base and how to generate revenue.
The report was easy to follow and contained relevant stuff. I thought it was relatively professional and it motivated why they believe in their idea.
It was overall easy to read but I found a few small language faults. For example “The team competence gaps…” should be “team’s” and “The realistic initial market for this venture is the city of Lund, here we ourselves have many connections,” should be “where” instead of “here” i believe. The problem is the struggle of planning events and inviting people and their solution is a new software focused more on the private person.
Yes, it describes well from a user’s perspective. Maybe the line about that many of the interviewees have been using social media recently and that it can be used for marketing is a bit unnecessary, or can at least be moved further down, cause I think it is pretty obvious that most students/young people are using social media more or less. The other parts about the MOM-test I think are very good and show that a problem exists with the current solutions that exist.
Not completely new but a bit different from the ones they mention and what I know. The biggest difference is that the main focus of the app is hosting events and more focus on the private consumer.
I think the biggest difference compared to existing alternatives is that events will be the main focus for the app rather than an extra feature and that it focuses more on the private person. I think that it is pretty easy to copy but since this group has people currently studying it will give them an edge in understanding the problem well. I think when the app has got a lot of users it will be hard to compete with but in the beginning when not a lot are using it another company could steal their potential future users.
It will generate revenue from event holders that want their event to be featured and also a small fee for the event venues when they get a reservation. Possible also from ads in the future. Not sure if it is realistic. If it costs to feature an event a lot of event holders might use for example Facebook instead and do it for free. If it is cheaper to reserve venues at other places it might also be tough to get people to pay extra for a reservation.
From what I have written previously I think that it is a good idea but a bit difficult to generate revenue.
Not sure exactly where the venture capital will be coming from.
I think that it is described well and includes both their strengths and what is missing. Contribution is also described well in the appendix. Very organized appendix.
I think it will be very difficult in the beginning of the project until it potentially has a lot of users cause it is difficult to invite people to an event if most people you want to invite don’t have the app. I also think it will be difficult to find ways of generating revenue until it has become an app that most students have and use. If it has a large user base event holders might pay a little extra to feature and promote their event on the app but if it doesn’t have a lot of users it will be hard to compete with already commonly used alternatives.
It is clear that students who are hosting or joining events are the users. Exactly who the customers are and how you make money from it might be a bit unclear I think.
They mention Facebook, Orbi, Hitract, Stuk and Ticketmaster and I can’t really think of any else.
That their app is actually better and easier to use for a private consumer because I think that is where they think they stand out compared to competitors.
Yes, it is realistic to start with students in Lund and then grow to other cities as well.
As I wrote before, the biggest problem will be to get an initial big user base and reach out to enough people. If a big amount of people use the app then I think getting more people will be very easy because then you need the app to not miss out on events.